This news feed was updated December 3, 2024 by adding a  summary of  research findings (see first bullet)

A recent review of the property boundary between William B. Umstead State Park and the Raleigh-Durham Airport Authority (RDUAA) managed property to the south, known as the Odd Fellows tract, shows that the boundary of the Odd Fellows tract has been shifted northerly, encroaching over 120 feet into William B. Umstead State Park.

In 1937, President Franklin D. Roosevelt authorized the United States Department of the Interior – National Park Service (NPS) to purchase a 209-acre parcel known as the PD Davis Tract to be a part of the Crabtree Creek Recreational Demonstration Area (RDA) (see Wake Register of Deeds, Book 743 page 499). The legal description for this tract includes boundaries that were re-confirmed via a survey in 1911 and remained unchanged through several sales after this survey and before becoming Park land.

The National Park Service confirmed the 1911 survey boundary as part of their 1937 purchase for the Park.

In 1943, the entire Crabtree Creek RDA, including all of the 209-acre PD Davis tract, was transferred to the State of North Carolina under the express condition that the land only be used for public park, recreation or conservation purposes (see the “Reverter Clause” in the Quitclaim Deed, Wake County Register of Deeds, Book 894 page 40). In 1955, the Crabtree Creek RDA, including the 209-acre PD Davis tract, was renamed William B. Umstead State Park.

The Odd Fellows tract, located just south of the 209-acre PD Davis tract, has been on the Umstead State Park acquisition list since 1935 and on the Park’s critical acquisition list since at least 1974.

Since the late 1800’s, deeds for the Odd Fellows tract indicate that it was “70 acres more or less.”  Two one-acre tracts were sold off in the late 1940’s and early 1950’s, leaving “68 acres, more or less.” In 1958, the International Order of Odd Fellows (IOOF) purchased this tract of “68 acres more or less” and 1 additional acre, resulting in 69 acres, more or less.

In 1976, the Airport surprisingly took management control of the Odd Fellows tract.  RDUAA employed their own surveyor who incorrectly shifted the Park boundary over 120’ to the north, taking Umstead State Park land, therefore Federal Park land.  As documented in RDUAA meeting minutes, the encroachment into Umstead State Park resulted in the “69 acres more or less” becoming approximately 83 acres, a difference of approximately 14 acres.  RDUAA did not inform anyone, including State Parks, regarding this large discrepancy in acreage.  As such, the resulting encroachment into Umstead State Park was buried.

For almost 50 years, RDUAA’s encroachment was not known nor was it an issue as the Airport expanded in the opposite direction from the Park and Odd Fellows was knowingly being used for recreation (including camping by the Boy Scouts) and conservation, consistent with the neighboring Park usage and consistent with long standing plans for this land to be a part of the Park.

Unfortunately, RDUAA leased the Odd Fellows Tract to a private mining company (Wake Stone Corporation) whose plans are to create a brand-new open mine rock quarry pit, a use that is not allowed on Park land.  Recently NC DEQ issued a mining permit to Wake Stone Corporation even though the mining permit application includes land belonging to Umstead State Park.    

Fortunately, this border issue can be easily resolved by re-surveying and marking the boundary as delineated by the metes and bounds in the 1937 NPS purchase deed (and as per the 1938 NPS Park map). Additionally, RDUAA should re-evaluate their lease with Wake Stone Corporation and DEQ should reassess Wake Stone’s Triangle Quarry Mining Permit modifications.

The good news is that Umstead State Park and the RDUAA managed property known as Odd Fellows are public lands managed by public bodies.  We call on the leadership of these public bodies to re-survey and correct the boundary of William B. Umstead State Park, honoring the NPS purchase deed and ensuring the encroachment is eliminated.

Supporting Documents are linked below:

• Historic records research summary, updated December 3, 2024
• Umstead Coalition's Press Release April 4, 2024
• Figures highlighting border encroachment by the RDU Airport, boundary dispute lands
• Memo from the Law Office of Patricia S. Horne, PLLC
• 1937 Deed of 209 acre PD Davis Tract purchased by the National Park Service, Department of the Interior, USA for what is now William B. Umstead State Park (Wake County Deed Book 743,Page499)
• 1943 Quitclaim Deed from the National Park Service to the State of North Carolina in what is now William B. Umstead State Park.  Parcel 3 (Tract No. 2A) is the 209 acre PD Davis tract
• 1937, April 27th. National Park Service survey acres re-confirmed to be 209 acres for the PD Davis tract
• 1935, April 3, National Park Service (NPS) appraises what we now call the Odd Fellows tract (and they made an offer to purchase for the park).  The NPS describes this tract as "The Extremely pretty and picturesque location gives an added value.  This "Odd Fellows" tract remains on the critical land acquisition list for William B. Umstead State Park
• 1976 June and July RDUAA Minutes.  The June 1, 1976 minutes reflect the correct acres for the Odd Fellows Tract.  One month later on July 6, 1976, the airport then thinks they are purchasing not 69 acres, but 83 acres!  Where did this surprise extra 14 acres come from?  The meets and bounds of the PD Davis tract prove that this extra 14 acres was already within William B. Umstead State Park and was federally-purchased land dedicated to remain in our State Park.  
• Details of the encroachment location and research of public records